I get noticed as a Bullitt or "cool car" just enough to remind me that people are paying attention. The valets at the garage where I park when I drive in to work comment on it or call me "Lt. Frank" which is kind of weird, but fun when you get it from the people who drive cars for a living.
One day when filling up, a guy driving a nice newish 911 comes over and asks me if that's the new Bullitt--it was early in the run. He complimented me on it, which I appreciated all the more coming from a guy with a "better" car. I actually regret not returning the compliment--it kind of made me feel like a d*ck.
The last time I drove in to work, I parked at a garage on Broadway (I work in San Franciso, forgot to mention). This means a bit of a walk for me but saves me $20 and if I'm not in a hurry, I try to do it. (I also frequently pick up my car just as the strippers at the clubs are going to work, so that's nice s well!) Well some kid, maybe late teens there with his Dad is obviously impressed and basically gawking. He ends up taking out his camera and snapping a picture as I'm exiting the lot. This kind of embararrased me, so I look away as I'm waiting on traffic to clear so I can pull out. And it's funny, as I type this I realize he may have inadvertantly got Enrico's (where Bullitt meets the guy who gives him the info on Ross) in the background!
Another complement was a scruffy, possibly homeless guy walking through traffic at a red light on Van Ness. He slowed and gently (to the point where I wasn't at all concerned) touched the front of the hood as he passed. Then he turns to me and grins and gives me a thumbs up. Daughter: "why did he do that Daddy?" Wife: "he was just saying he like the car" Daughter: "oh."
I think I get noticed less since I removed the faux gas cap, and I generally keep the car less clean than it should be. I definitely get more comments when it's clean.
In short, it's fun to get noticed for the right reasons. It's not flashy, so if anyone calls you out on it, they're people who appeciate the same things we do.